Schools
hdfs 239

  • College entrance requires certain courses. How do kids meet them?
    • They don't know requirements
    • Parents and teachers don't know requirements
    • Tracking
  • Dornbusch study:
    • Sample is balanced so all ethnic groups are equal in ability and sex
      • Who gets put where?
      • How do they get there?
      • What does it mean for them?

       

  • Who gets put where?
    • Tracking by ethnicity
      • large ethnic differences in placement that can't be due to ability
    • Is it SES?
      • higher SES, more likely to be taking college prep courses
    • Does SES explain the ethnic differences?
      • within ethnicity, SES predicts college placement
      • within SES, ethnicity is important
        • Asian is always highest percentage
        • Ethnic gap is biggest in middle and upper class
        • benefits of SES vary by class, with biggest benefits for Whites

         

 
  • Why do they get put in different tracks?
    • 8th grade: Algebra v. Algebra .5
      • based on negative behavior comments, grades, standardized test scores
      • no evidence for discrimination against African Americans or Hispanics at time of placement
      • some evidence for pro-Asian placement
      • parents can fight placement IF THEY KNOW
        • 31% of African-American and Hispanic students who are in top 50% think they are on college track, but aren't
  • Does tracking matter?
  • Summary:
    • Neither kids, their parents, nor their teachers really have a good understanding of college entrance requirements.
    • Whether you meet requirements is determined by what track you are in in school.
    • Low SES, African- & Hispanic-Americans are disproportionately likely to be placed in low track courses
    • Although track placement can be changed if parents argue against it, most parents don't realize that their kids have been tracked out of college-bound courses, because the children don't know
    • Track placement is important, because kids of equal ability who start out in different tracks wind up in very different places.
    • Small initial differences can have very large consequences.